Friend visiting, pick a lake for him

[Home Wood]

I have a friend planning to come visit in mid May from Massachusetts and ofcourse we are going fishing. I want to take him to a lake where he has a good chance to catch decent fish. Out of our local lakes, Falls, Jordan, Harris, etc.. Which one would you recommend? I'm shying away from Falls, because I've simply never done that well there. I haven't been to Harris yet (so no opinion on that lake), but plan to before he comes down. This is for bass fishing, but we may try to catch a few cats.