Here's a report after 2 years of service on my 12 foot alumacraft:
PROS
Inexpensive
Has not left me stranded!
Pushes me along fine if I'm solo
Usually starts fairly easily
Routine maintenance is fairly easy
CONS
A bit noisy, especially when first started.
A couple of times has been hard to start, but ran and started fine once warm.
Recently running rough, think it was bad gas, seems to be resolved.
One of the fuel lines has small cracks (but no leaks) after 2 years of use.
When you put it in reverse, there's a catch that engages to keep the motor in the water. Mine often doesn't "catch". Probably should get warranty service (2 years), but hate to be without the motor! (also, rarely use reverse since I have a stern-mount trolling motor).
For me, it was all about the price! Got it on sale.