I have some negative info... Everything that is returned to Academy winds up in the sporting goods auctions I attend. I mean everything. Kayaks, bikes, pelican bass boats, etc. But I've never seen a trailer there. Implies the quality is fairly good.
I would not buy the cheaper of the two on their web site... I'm allergic to 8" tires. The next one up has 12", which are small but usable, but those 8" tires will limit your speed or burn out quickly.
That's all I can offer you.... Slightly better than nothing, but close to it.