The wind and waves down here on the coast slapping against the boat are hard on the rivets too.Mine is riveted, decision based solely on price. It is a 2000 Alumacraft, 12'. Has held up well to date. I treat her pretty well, but she gets slapped around a bit by the chop on Kerr Lake sometimes. I would say if you take decent care of it, a riveted boat will hold up well. Of course, a lot of people are hard on jon boats, dragging them to ponds, throwing them in pickups, etc.