Ok my 2 cents, and my question.
1...Demo as many boats as you can! All kinds, Sit ins, sit ons, 10 ft 12 ft 14 ft, all of em! Skinny wide etc...
2...Why does it have to be a "starter kayak"? I did that, bought a yak for $300ish, loved it, but of course a few months later, when I was ear deep in this whole kayak fishing game, I was like ****, I want a bigger and better one now!!! So in the long run I should have just put that 300 towards my 2nd yak, manta ray 14, right off the bat. If money right now is the issue, then I understand...If not, take your time demo yaks, and just get the one you LOVE now...
I would let you try my Manta 14 if you are ever in charlotte, great boat, its a BIG BOY yak, and im not big, 5'8 175 but I still love it..